RecycLiCo Battery Materials (TSX.V:  AMY; OTCQB:  AMYZF; FSE:  ID4): as a result of a review by the British Columbia Securities Commission (“BCSC”), RecycLiCo Battery Materials (“RecycLiCo Battery Materials” or the “Company”) has filed on SEDAR an Amended Technical Report (the “Report”) authored by Tetra Tech for the Company’s 100% owned Artillery Peak Manganese Project (Mohave County, Arizona) to address concerns raised by the BCSC.  The public is cautioned not to rely on the Company’s previously filed Report wherein mineral reserves are disclosed.  A summary of the Company’s responses to the BCSC’s concerns follows: 

1)    The certificates of the qualified persons have been amended to ensure that the authors are qualified persons for their respective Report sections.

2)    Every section of the Report is covered by at least one statement of responsibility on the certificates of qualified persons.

3)    Section 12 is expanded to elaborate on the reliability of assay results based on comparisons of twin holes.  It explains why the assay data base is sufficiently reliable to estimate mineral resources.

4)    Section 12 is expanded to include the results and interpretation of the 525 samples check assay program that was sent to a secondary laboratory for check analysis.

5)    Section 14 of the report has been amended to explain why the use of the global bulk density of 2.1 for the manganese ore is reliable for the estimation of resources.

6)    The electrolytic manganese metal (“EMM”) market is secretive and highly concentrated with over 97% of global EMM production sourced from China in 2010. South Africa, the only other EMM producing country, accounted for the remaining 2.1% of global supply.  Very little information is available in the public domain as producers and consumers are extremely secretive about any commercial arrangements, and specific EMM market forecasts for metal production/consumption are regarded as proprietary competitive advantages.  To counter this lack of information, the Company engaged CPM Group to prepare a market study, including an EMM price forecast which was being used in the Report.

Owing to the lack of publicly available information on the EMM market, the Company does not have information from other, independent industry producers/consumers to confirm CPM Group’s projected pricing over the 25 year forecast period.  As a result, the Company has agreed to change the Base Case to the more conservative 3 Year Trailing Average from the CPM Expected Case.  An alternate price sensitivity case, 3 Year Trailing Average Price Reduced by 25%, has also been added.

A summary from the Report of the pre-tax financial model results is presented below:



NPV @ 0%
($US million)
NPV @ 5%
($US million)
($US million)
NPV @ 10%
($US million)

Pay Back

Base Case:  3 Year Trailing Average Price



91.2 (22.9) (74.4)


Alternate 1:  CPM Expected Price Forecast


1360.0 641.5 402.9 289.4


Alternate 2:  CPM Up-side Price Forecast


1895.3 940.0 623.2 472.3


Alternate 3:  CPM Down-side Price Forecast


785.4 311.0 153.6 79.0


Alternate 4:  3 Year Trailing Average Price Reduced by 25%


(386.1) (380.0) (371.3) (364.3) N/A


As a result of the amended Base Case and Alternate 4 having negative NPV at an 8% discount rate, the project is deemed to be not economic.  Accordingly, Section 15 of the Report was amended to show there are no mineral reserves for the Project that meets the CIM definition and consequently the mineral reserves for the Project were retracted. Section 16 has also been amended to show the indicated resources within the open pit shell that have been used for planning purposes.

7)    Section 3 has been amended to include the appropriate disclosure necessary to support the EMM price forecast developed by CPM Group, and Section 22 has been expanded to describe CPM Group’s forecasting methodology to support the EMM price forecast developed by CPM Group. 

Section 22 has been amended to provide a better description of the two tier pricing for EMM imported into the United States and EMM sold outside of the United States.

The Base Case EMM prices is the weighted average of the 3 years trailing average world price ($US1.36/lb.) applied to 40% of contemplated product sales, and the 3 year trailing average US price ($US1.66/lb.) applied to 60% of the contemplated product sales.

Price forecasts for the CPM Alternate Cases 1, 2 and 3 are from the CPM Group EMM Market Study Report “Manganese Metal Outlook, February 2012”.  The EMM prices in the report are specified as projected world prices, and these prices were applied to 40% of the metal production contemplated for overseas sales.  For the 60% of metal production contemplated for domestic sales, the EMM prices in the report were increased by 14% to account for the tariff on EMM imported into the US.

8)    For clarity, the information regarding taxation has been expanded and moved from Section 24 to Section 22.  After tax financial results for the Base Case have been included in Section 22 and are summarized as follows:  IRR = 6.14%; NPV at 8% = ($54.4 million); and Payback = 10.7 years.  The other Alternate Case scenarios do not factor in taxes, which could result in lower economic results than projected on a pre-tax basis.

9)    Section 14.1 has been amended in the Report to describe the additional resources that have been found and tested at other locations within the Company’s land holdings that have not been used in the commercial mining scenario described in the Report.  This information was originally presented in the report entitled “Mineral Resource Evaluation Report on the Artillery Mountain Manganese Property, Mohave County, Arizona, U.S.A.” by Norm Tribe, P.Eng., dated September 1st, 2011 and Amended December 1st, 2011.

The following table summarizes the indicated and inferred resources for the remainder of the property.

Summary of Mineral Resource Estimates from Tribe (2011).  Grade Cutoff 0.90% Mn.

Deposit/Region Resource
Average Grade
(Mn %)
Maggie Mine 113,663,426              2.90
Shannon Mine      1,507,022              3.96
Love’s, Hurley, and Planche Mines    3,616,579              5.16
South Chapin, Burro, Price, and Priceless Zones    24,788,169              2.87
Total Tonnes/Grade 143,575,196              2.98
Maggie Mine    40,360,508              2.71
Shannon Mine      4,298,133              2.74
Love’s, Hurley, and Planche Mines      4,110,834              4.00
South Chapin, Burro, Price, and Priceless Zones      5,930,764              2.87
Total Tonnes/Grade    54,700,239              2.83


10)  The EMM price inconsistencies identified on pages 1-15, 16-7, and 22-1 have been corrected.

11)  The corporate presentations “Preliminary Feasibility Press Conference” dated May 18, 2012 and “Manganese Pit Wall” dated May 31, 2012, as well as the Corporate Fact Sheet on the Company’s website, have been amended to correspond to the information presented in the Amended Technical Report.

About Tetra Tech

Tetra Tech is a leading provider of consulting, engineering, program management, construction management, and technical services.  The Company supports government and commercial clients by providing innovative solutions to complex problems focused on water, environment, energy, infrastructure, and natural resources.  The company has been servicing the mining industry for more than 40 years and has established a reputation for successfully executing NI 43-101 compliant feasibility studies that meet the scrutiny of the international financing community.  With more than 13,000 employees worldwide, Tetra Tech’s capabilities span the entire project life cycle.  The company has more than 330 offices worldwide, including locations in Canada as well as in Arizona and Nevada in close proximity to the Artillery Peak project.

About CPM Group (

CPM Group is the world’s premier commodities research and consulting company.  The firm’s primary focus is on precious, industrial, and specialty metals, in addition to undertaking research and analysis across all commodities markets.  In the ferroalloy industry CPM Group has developed a top-rated expertise in molybdenum, vanadium, manganese and chromium, as well as other minor metals.  CPM Group provides a suite of research and consulting services related to the financial management of commodities exposure, including fundamental market research and analysis, consulting and advisory services, commodities management and asset management services, and corporate finance advisory.  Founded in 1986, CPM Group is known for its research and analysis of the metals markets, its overall economic analysis of commodities markets, and its expertise in financial engineering, using derivatives to structure optimized positions for commercial hedgers and institutional and high net worth individual investors.

About Manganese

China controls electrolytic manganese production supplying and producing 98% of the world’s needs (3 billion pounds per year).

There is no substitute for manganese in steel (total manganese market greater than 33 billion pounds per year, fourth largest traded metal).

Manganese is a critical metal at risk for supply disruptions in the United States as there is no U.S. production. EMM’s greatest uses are the upgrading of specialty steel (74%), and the manufacture of aluminum alloys (12%), electronics (2%), and other applications (12%).

Electrolytic manganese dioxide (EMD) for the battery industry is expected to be the fastest-growing segment of the manganese market.  Ford Motors predicts production of hybrid electric vehicles will account for 25% of its entire vehicle line-up by 2020, and Hyundai has committed a lifetime guarantee to their hybrid electric vehicles that use lithium-ion batteries with manganese spinel.

China has a 20% export duty on EMM and the U.S. has a 14% import duty.

About RecycLiCo Battery Materials

RecycLiCo Battery Materials is a diversified specialty and critical metal Company focusing on potentially becoming a producer of electrolytic manganese metal, electrolytic manganese dioxide and chemical manganese dioxide from its Arizona Manganese Project.

This release has been reviewed by Michael MacLeod, P. Eng., a qualified person pursuant to National Instrument 43-101.

On behalf of Management

RecycLiCo Battery Materials 

Larry W. Reaugh
President and Chief Executive Officer

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

The Toronto Stock Exchange has not reviewed and does not accept responsibility for the adequacy or accuracy of this release. This news release may contain certain “Forward-Looking Statements” within the meaning of Section 21E of the United States Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended. All statements, other than statements of historical fact, included herein are forward-looking statements that involve various risks and uncertainties. There can be no assurance that such statements will prove to be accurate, and actual results and future events could differ materially from those anticipated in such statements. Important factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from the Company’s expectations are disclosed in the Company’s documents filed from time to time with the Toronto Stock Exchange, the British Columbia Securities Commission and the US Securities and Exchange Commission.

Latest Press Releases